Skip to content
Home » News & Updates » When Narrative Overtakes Fundamentals in the Stock Market

When Narrative Overtakes Fundamentals in the Stock Market

In 2025, storylines – not spreadsheets – increasingly drive share prices, volatility and alpha. Markets now price perception before performance, with narratives forming faster than fundamentals and often becoming the market’s default valuation model. Understanding how these stories accelerate, peak and reverse has become essential to anticipating market moves and identifying early inflection points.

For years, narrative was treated as something softer than fundamentals, an auxiliary signal rather than a pricing mechanism. But the 2025 market environment has made one truth unavoidable: narrative is now a first-order driver of equity valuation. Perception shifts ahead of performance, share prices move with the story, and fundamentals adjust last, if they adjust at all. Across EVs, aerospace, consumer health, semiconductors and apparel, this dynamic repeats consistently. At Atlastic, where we analyse millions of news articles across 100+ markets, we observe narrative inflection points days or even weeks before they appear in financial models. Narrative has become measurable – and it moves markets.

Narrative Momentum as a Tradable Factor

The rise of narrative-driven pricing is not a behavioural anomaly but a structural development shaped by three decades of evolving market mechanics. In the 1990s, scale and operational leverage were the core sources of advantage; markets rewarded asset intensity and globalised efficiency. The 2000s shifted value toward digital platforms, where network effects, data accumulation and ecosystem position defined competitive strength.

By the 2010s, intangible assets and low interest rates made long-duration growth narratives central to valuation. Markets became comfortable projecting multi-year trajectories, and the credibility of a company’s story became a key input to its multiple.

The early 2020s brought heightened uncertainty: geopolitical shocks, volatile supply chains and expanding regulatory scrutiny made fundamentals harder to forecast. Meanwhile, public information volume exploded, increasingly overwhelming traditional analytical capacity.

By 2025, these forces converged into a new dominant driver: narrative velocity – the speed at which a storyline forms, spreads and substitutes for incomplete fundamentals. In a world of information abundance and attention scarcity, the prevailing narrative becomes the default valuation model. Stocks trade on the trajectory of perception, not on the trailing P&L.

Why Narrative Velocity Now Drives Markets

Information overload elevates narrative as the filtering mechanism that simplifies complexity into an investable signal. Regulatory frameworks – from CSDDD to climate disclosures to cybersecurity rules – institutionalise reputation as a quantifiable financial variable. Quant and semi-quant models ingest trust, sentiment and controversy signals in real time, often shaping portfolio decisions before fundamentals update. Perception becomes predictive because it consistently moves ahead of performance.

Five Examples of Narrative Leading Price Action

Before the cases, an unavoidable disclaimer: Tesla is the most overused narrative-versus-fundamentals example in global finance. But because it remains the clearest and most instructive, I am still including it:-)

Tesla (TSLA): Narrative as a Long-Duration Asset: Tesla’s overarching storyline; “the EV revolution is unstoppable”, has repeatedly overshadowed operational realities. Even as gross margins declined from roughly 29% in 2021 to under 19% in 2024 and global EV competition intensified, markets maintained a durable belief in Tesla’s inevitability. The stock rallied more than 103% in H1 2023, often traded at forward P/E multiples above 60, and continued to behave more like a high-growth software name than an automaker. The narrative acted like a long-duration intangible asset: as long as belief endured, price followed.

Meta (META): Narrative Overextension and Reversal: In 2021–22, Meta became a case study in narrative excess. The metaverse storyline drove enormous media volume and investor enthusiasm, pushing the stock to ~$382, despite slowing ad growth, rising competition and capex surging from $19B to $32B. When the storyline collapsed, so did the price – falling to $88, a 77% drawdown, long before fundamentals normalised. The reversal was driven by belief, not balance sheets.

Palantir (PLTR): The Narrative Shortcut Around Fundamentals: Palantir’s position at the intersection of “AI + national security” provided one of the strongest story compounds in the market.  During 2023, shares rose from $6.50 to $21 – a 223% gain – even though revenue growth remained modest and profitability thin. Any positive AI news became a narrative accelerant, creating a form of convexity where perception moved faster than evidence. When enthusiasm plateaued in mid-2024, the retracement toward $14–15 occurred with similar narrative force.

Boeing (BA): The Speed of a Negative Narrative Spiral: The 737 MAX 9 door-plug incident on 5 January 2024 triggered an immediate and global narrative shift: “Boeing has a systemic safety problem.” Within a week, the stock dropped 10%, and by year-end it had fallen 31%, making it the worst performer in the Dow. At the moment the narrative formed, fundamentals were broadly unchanged – revenue stable, backlog intact, guidance unaltered. Only months later did operational consequences (FAA intervention, delivery delays) materialise. The narrative moved first; the numbers followed the story.

Adidas (ADS): Narrative Contagion and Brand Fragility: After Adidas severed ties with Kanye West in late 2022, the market rapidly converged on a storyline of ethical exposure and over-reliance on Yeezy. This drove the stock from €336 at its peak to ~€105 before any financial damage was visible. Actual consequences – inventory write-downs, margin compression, guidance cuts – emerged later, long after the price had already adjusted. The narrative priced the damage early; the P&L delivered it eventually.

How Investors Can Use Narrative for Alpha

With narratives forming faster than fundamentals, timing becomes critical. The key is not static sentiment, but narrative velocity – the acceleration or deceleration of perception that precedes volatility. Investors can build narrative-aware universes to detect early controversy risk, identify positive inflection points or flag developing narrative cliffs. When perception stabilises or reverses ahead of fundamentals, it creates opportunities for both long and short strategies. Atlastic is designed for this reality, transforming global media behaviour into quant-ready trust signals that feed directly into risk, allocation and factor models.

The Age of Perception-Driven Markets

In an ideal world, story and substance would move together. In today’s market, story often leads – and substance chases. Investors who ignore narrative risk leave performance on the table. Those who measure it gain visibility earlier in the cycle, where alpha lives.

Thanks for reading – we’ll be back soon with more curated insights. At Atlastic, we work to translate the world’s media perception into clear, investment-ready signals. Want to learn more? Book a demo here.